| Name | Years Served | Name | Years Served |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sydney "Frank" Van Sise | 1927-1930 | Anton Chaulus | 1987 |
| Daniel Van Sise | 1927-1931 | Carl Gianino | 1977-1991 |
| Albert F. Budd | 1927-1942 | George Wulforst | 1988-2000 |
| Horace J. Allen | 1927-1943 | Henry Marzola | 1975-2002 |
| Daniel Van Sise | 1942-1947 | William Strong | 1988-2002 |
| Jerome Suydam | 1943-1949 | Peter J. Morley | 1966-2003 |
| Elliot A. Ure | 1947-1951 | Richard Meinhardt | 2003-2004 |
| James A. Devine | 1931-1952 | Ronald Geraci | 1992-2006 |
| Henry Marzola | 1950-1954 | Dennis Hendrickson | 2001-2007 |
| James Allen | 1952-1957 | Giovanni Graceffa | 2003-2007 |
| Arthur L. Kappstatter | 1955-1959 | Daniel Percell | 2005-2009 |
| Willard E. Thompson | 1951-1966 | Christian Pieper | 2007-2010 |
| Eugene R. Williams | 1927-1971 | Edward Keenan | 2004-2011 |
| Harry Watson | 1957-1972 | Christian Pieper | 2007-2010 |
| William Rynsky | 1960-1974 | Frank Vasile | 2006-2011 |
| Joseph T. Simone | 1972-1976 | Roy Brouillard | 2008-2012 |
| John Dannefelser | 1973-1977 | Thomas Feeney | 2013-2016 |
| James McInnes, Jr. | 1930-1987 | Andrew Dick | 2017-2020 |
| Robert J. Doran | 1978-1987 | Robert Swanson | 2011-2023 |
HEADQUARTERS
50 Cold Spring Rd, Syosset, NY 11791
STATION 2
156 Woodbury Rd, Woodbury, NY 11797
STATION 3
205 S Oyster Bay Rd, Syosset, NY 11791
